HBO. Its not TV... its HBO.
SERIES | MOVIES | SPORTS | DOCUMENTARIES | HBO FILMS | SCHEDULE | ON DEMAND | SHOP HBO | GET HBO
Welcome Guest

ERIC or BILL?

[Replies: 2,048]
If you've read the books, which do you prefer?

I'm ERIC all the way!

--
--
~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~

GET OFF YOUR ASS AND VOTE OR YOU HAVE NO RIGHT TO BITCH.
Last Post Sep 13, 2009 5:28 PM by: _MAFIOSA
TrueBloodlover
Posts: 145
Registered: 10/8/08
(309 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 10:06 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
I have not read the books yet, but from the show alone and not seeing Eric much other then that one show.

I'm on team Bill, and he seems more real in the down to earth level. Eric seems like the traditional vampire, larks in the shadows and isn't one to be gentleman like as Bill is.
beans22206
Posts: 600
Registered: 9/30/08
(308 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 9:47 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> Hence, she created Eric. Eric, however, took on a
> life on of his own and she started to love writing
> for him. So, she sold out Bill for Eric. It's
> happened to me in movies. I've had several script
> analysis come back stating that I've given the best
> lines to a character that isn't the star.
>

>
> See how powerful and charming Eric is? He can win any
> woman's heart, even his "maker". ;)
>
> --
> "What I got here may be boring but it's safe, and
> after the past couple of nights, safe sounds pretty
> good to me right now."


hahahahaha!! Yes, I see. I'm still team Bill because I'm pretty sure that Ms. Harris didn't start this series because of Eric and I doubt she started it because of Sookie, because until Bill, there was nothing to write about Sookie. She started this story because of Bill. He is Sookie's hero and her soulmate. All others will pale in comparison to him.

--
We vampires are always in some kind of trouble. I prefer to be in it with you. ~ Bill

Team Bill and Sookie Forever!!!!
beans22206
Posts: 600
Registered: 9/30/08
(307 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 9:36 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> From the books definitely Eric.
>
> I started out a Sookie/Bill shipper in the beginning.
> Didn't notice all the really good Eric moments from
> m the very beginning. But little things started to
> creep me out about Bill.
>
> How he always had to get the extra sexual pleasure of
> sucking Sookie's blood every time they had sex. He
> couldn't have settled for a bottle of True Blood
> every now and then so she wouldn't become anemic?
> She asked for every third night off so she could
> d recover. She had to ask. When she started to take
> iron he complained that it gave a bad taste to the
> blood. GRRR
>
> Bill never understood her jokes. Eric did. Bill's
> gifts made Sookie feel like a kept woman. He just
> didn't get it. Eric understood what she needed and
> what she would accept, flowers, gravel for her drive,
> new coat to replace the blood splattered one, etc.
>
> Near the end of book 2 When Bill claims Sookie is
> his, she gives him the finger. Eric laughed. Bill
> looked shocked that Sookie would do something so
> un-lady-like. Eric explained to Bill, "she's telling
> us she doesn't belong to anyone, she's her own
> person". Bill never got Sookie, Eric did. Because
> Bill is so secretive, their relationship is all
> angsty. She never got Bill either. Eric is so open
> and up front that she does understand him. And with
> the blood bond between them from book 7 they both
> experience what the other is feeling.
>
> Now I will say that Bill on the show is more likable
> than in the book and Stephen's voice can really be
> sexy, but I can't get past what I know of his
> character. It's still Eric all the way.


Team Bill here and I'm defending. I don't know any normal man who wouldn't have sex as much as he can and with as much pleasure as he can. Also, given the fact that Bill isn't telpathic, unless Sookie said something, he wouldn't know how taxing sex with him was being on her. After all, he's not human. And he did apologise and accommodate her request for every 3rd night off.

As for the bad tasting blood, I wonder how many of us would be going down on our significant other on a regular basis if they had bad tasting *love juice* and that's what Sookie's blood is to Bill. There's actually a sex in the city episode where Samantha breaks up with a guy bcause she simply couldn't take the taste of his love juice.

As for not getting a joke, I don't think that's grounds to break up with someone.

As for giving Bill the finger when he claimed her as his, Bill was simply speaking in vampire terms. Sookie, by now, should understand that. So, the finger thing was completely rude and unnecessary.

--
We vampires are always in some kind of trouble. I prefer to be in it with you. ~ Bill

Team Bill and Sookie Forever!!!!

--
Edited by beans22206 at 10/08/2008 7:18 AM PDT
knr5501
Posts: 1,599
Registered: 9/27/08
(306 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 6:45 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> I did not ellaborate as i should have:
> here are my points to why i like Bill
>
> 1. he tells her he loves her and means it.
>
> 2. yes he fucked up royally several times but it
> could be worse (some women stay with men who hit them
> and abuse them in many ways.)
>
> 3. he apologized when Sookie found out about Lenora
>
> 4. Although i would slap him if i could, HE DID TRY
> to provide for Sookie once Lenora made him be her
> bitch again.
>
> 5. HE DIDN'T GIVE UP SOOKIE when he was being beaten,
> he was protecting her while he was being tortured.
>
> 6. He has been a good guy even though ( i have only
> read up to five but from what i hear...) he did come
> first under orders.
>
> 7. Bill really fell in love with her and was gentle
> and passionate with her.
>
> 8. yes he did ignore her a bit in book 3 but that
> happens with all relationships when men (or women)
> are abosred in work. (boyfriend does it every time
> he's working on his music, but he later makes up for
> it...believe me ;) so please don't hold that against
> him too much
>
> 9. Every time she had been in the hospital, he was
> there and made HER feel safe and happy.
>
> 10. Although he was blind to how her finances were,
> they didnt exactly discuss them between each other
> (my boyfriend didnt realize how bad i needed help
> UNTIL AFTER he moved in with me...then i just tell
> 'hey babe, i need to borrow some money to fix this or
> to pay this...and he gives it to me. Though i do plan
> to pay him back one day...once i get in order. i have
> lost my job got one lost it again and now i'm in the
> union for MANDALAY BAY hotel and ill be out of debt
> in ten months!!! yay me! anyway...sorry went a little
> off topic...) anyway as i was saying, maybe Bill
> didn't realize her gravel was bad because he didn't
> t have it on his yard and didn't know when it was
> good or bad, think of that one mon amies?
>
> ok i'll be back in a bit, i'm working on another BILL
> X SOOKIE story hehe later haters (of team bill) and
> lovers (of team bill) also i'm up to debates as long
> as its in a friendly way
>
> --
> Bill + Sookie = Hawt Vamp sex + Great Romance


Vamplov:

Very well said! TEAM BILL ALL THE WAY!!!!

*******************************************
TEAM BILL FOREVER
Posts: 3
Registered: 10/8/08
(305 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 12:41 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> For Eric lovers out there, I found an article where
> AB states Eric will be a main character in the
> series...enjoy:
>
> http://www.scifi.com/sfw/interviews/sfw19397.html
>
> **********************************************


Thanks this was very helpful!

I like Bill in the T.V. show right now, because he's so sincere with sookie and I love in the first book how he retains that sexual relationship with sookie.

BUT it sounds like I'm going to like Eric's character later.

I don't like the "look" they gave Eric in the T.V. Show though....
dimmplzz
Posts: 113
Registered: 9/29/08
(304 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 8, 2008 12:36 AM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
I'm just on Book 2 now and loving the series, so far still Bill.

Even after the betrayal, I still maybe prefer Bill and Sookie vs Sookie and Eric.

--
"Sookie is Mine"
http://mytruebloodtv.com
vamplov
Posts: 16
Registered: 10/3/08
(303 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 11:15 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
I did not ellaborate as i should have:
here are my points to why i like Bill

1. he tells her he loves her and means it.

2. yes he fucked up royally several times but it could be worse (some women stay with men who hit them and abuse them in many ways.)

3. he apologized when Sookie found out about Lenora

4. Although i would slap him if i could, HE DID TRY to provide for Sookie once Lenora made him be her bitch again.

5. HE DIDN'T GIVE UP SOOKIE when he was being beaten, he was protecting her while he was being tortured.

6. He has been a good guy even though ( i have only
read up to five but from what i hear...) he did come first under orders.

7. Bill really fell in love with her and was gentle and passionate with her.

8. yes he did ignore her a bit in book 3 but that happens with all relationships when men (or women) are abosred in work. (boyfriend does it every time he's working on his music, but he later makes up for it...believe me ;) so please don't hold that against him too much

9. Every time she had been in the hospital, he was there and made HER feel safe and happy.

10. Although he was blind to how her finances were, they didnt exactly discuss them between each other (my boyfriend didnt realize how bad i needed help UNTIL AFTER he moved in with me...then i just tell 'hey babe, i need to borrow some money to fix this or to pay this...and he gives it to me. Though i do plan to pay him back one day...once i get in order. i have lost my job got one lost it again and now i'm in the union for MANDALAY BAY hotel and ill be out of debt in ten months!!! yay me! anyway...sorry went a little off topic...) anyway as i was saying, maybe Bill didn't realize her gravel was bad because he didn't have it on his yard and didn't know when it was good or bad, think of that one mon amies?

ok i'll be back in a bit, i'm working on another BILL X SOOKIE story hehe later haters (of team bill) and lovers (of team bill) also i'm up to debates as long as its in a friendly way

--
Bill + Sookie = Hawt Vamp sex + Great Romance
eripmav
Posts: 996
Registered: 9/4/08
(302 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 10:11 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
Hence, she created Eric. Eric, however, took on a life on of his own and she started to love writing for him. So, she sold out Bill for Eric. It's happened to me in movies. I've had several script analysis come back stating that I've given the best lines to a character that isn't the star.


See how powerful and charming Eric is? He can win any woman's heart, even his "maker". ;)

--
"What I got here may be boring but it's safe, and after the past couple of nights, safe sounds pretty good to me right now."
Posts: 83
Registered: 10/7/08
(301 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 9:15 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
I like Bill a lot & actually felt sorry for him in the last couple of books. He really tries to make amends & prove himself & his love for Sookie...but....I'm an ERIC girl....all the way!!!! He just gets her not to mention the blood bond. After the revelations about Bill are made to Sookie later on, she will never trust him again. The hurt is too strong. For those of you who haven't read the books. Read them or get them on tape. They're awesome!
knr5501
Posts: 1,599
Registered: 9/27/08
(300 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 8:57 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
After Sunday's episode, unless AB makes Eric out to some sort of Vampire "Saint", it will be very hard for me to leave Team Bill!!!

Oh boy...I can just imagine Mafiosa's response...lol!
***************************************
TEAM BILL FOREVER
beans22206
Posts: 600
Registered: 9/30/08
(299 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 5:10 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> Look, Charlaine Harris started by writing this
> beautiful love story between Bill and Sookie. Then
> she changed the character of Bill and made him
> selfish, grouchyand disturbing. In my mind Bill is
> the Bill of the 1rst book. I do that with all the
> show, books or movies that take characters down a
> road I don't agree with. I love Eric but bring back
> the real Bill please.


ITA!!! I am an aspiring screenwriter and I believe I know what happened. Charlaine started out with a great character in Bill and a wonderful love story between him and Sookie. She had to create a powerful nemisis, which is standard in everystory. You have to give the star a more powerful enemy, so his triumph mean that much more. Hence, she created Eric. Eric, however, took on a life on of his own and she started to love writing for him. So, she sold out Bill for Eric. It's happened to me in movies. I've had several script analysis come back stating that I've given the best lines to a character that isn't the star.

--
We vampires are always in some kind of trouble. I prefer to be in it with you. ~ Bill

Team Bill and Sookie Forever!!!!
Wildcelt
Posts: 734
Registered: 9/18/08
(298 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 4:23 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
I'd like to see more of Eric's character before I choose. The grand total of maybe 2 minutes of screen time with Eric was just not enough, compared to the screen time Bill has had.

But Eric gave me chills...and in very good ways!:-x
vgannon50
Posts: 2,468
Registered: 10/7/08
(297 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 3:52 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
Fang Fan ....it is easy to make that mistake but there are 2 places for those of us who have read the books to post. The spoiler thread and someone else has one about If you've read the books how does the show measure up or something like that...see you there
FangFan
Posts: 21,104
Registered: 9/23/08
(296 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 3:41 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
> FangFan:
> Bill "hasn't drunk Sookie's blood yet~ Sookie HAS
> Drank from his arm after she was beaten up by
> the Rattray's"
>
> FangFan, Please if you have any Spoilers put them
> only on the Spoiler thread!!
> There are some of us here that "Don't want to know
> what happens and Don't want to read the books~Yet!


Hey, wait a minute! I was replying to posts with the same kind of information in them. In fact, this whole thread talks about similar things. I apologize for spoiling, but I was just going along with what has already been posted in here.

--
"Pretty exotic stuff for a telepathic barmaid from Northern Louisiana" (Sookie - Book 1)
Marleneemm
Posts: 29,581
Registered: 12/9/02
(295 of 2049)

Re: ERIC or BILL?

Oct 7, 2008 3:37 PM
Rate this post:
1 star
2 stars
3 stars
4 stars
5 stars
FangFan:
Bill "hasn't drunk Sookie's blood yet~ Sookie HAS
Drank from his arm after she was beaten up by
the Rattray's"

FangFan, Please if you have any Spoilers put them
only on the Spoiler thread!!
There are some of us here that "Don't want to know
what happens and Don't want to read the books~Yet!
Page: of 137